ADMINISTRATION AND MANAGEMENT OF INDIAN EXPENDITURE.*
Dear Lord Welby,—I beg to place before you and other Members of the Commission a few notes about the scope and importance of its work.
The Reference consists of two parts. The first is: “To enquire into the Administration and Management of the Military and Civil Expenditure incurred under the authority of the Secretary of State for India in Council, or of the Government of India.”
This enquiry requires to ascertain whether the present system of the Administration and Management of Expenditure, both here and in India, secures sufficiency and efficiency of services, and all other satisfactory results, at an economical and affordable cost; whether there is any peculiar inherent defect, or what Mr. Bright called “fundamental error”† in this system; and the necessity or otherwise of every expenditure.
I shall deal with these items as briefly as possible, simply as suggestively and not exhaustively:—
“Sufficiency.”—The Duke of Devonshire (then, 1883, Lord Hartington) as Secretary of State for India has said‡: “There can in my opinion be very little doubt that India is insufficiently governed.”
Sir William Hunter has said§: “The constant demand for improvement in the general executive will require an increasing amount of administrative labour."
"Efficiency".—It stands to reason that when a country is "insufficiently governed," it cannot be efficiently governed, however competent each servant, high and low, may be. The Duke of Devonshire assumes as much in the words, "if the country is to be better governed." So does Sir William Hunter: "If we are to govern the Indian people efficiently and cheaply." These words will be found in the fuller extracts given further on.
"Economical and Affordable Cost."—The Duke of Devonshire has said*: "The Government of India cannot afford to spend more than they do on the administration of the country, and if the country is to be better governed, that can only be done by the employment of the best and most intelligent of the Natives in the Service."
Sir William Hunter, after referring to the good work done by the Company, of the external and internal protection, has said†: "But the good work thus commenced has assumed such dimensions under the Queen's Government of India that it can no longer be carried on, or even supervised by imported labour from England except at a cost which India cannot sustain," . . . "forty years hereafter we should have had an Indian Ireland multiplied fifty-fold on our hands. The condition of things in India compels the Government to enter on these problems. Their solution and the constant demand for improvement in the general executive, will require an increasing amount of administrative labour. India cannot afford to pay for that labour at the English rates, which are the highest in the world for official service. But she can afford to pay for it at her own Native rates, which are perhaps the lowest in the world for such employment." "You cannot work with imported labour as cheaply as you can with Native labour, and I regard the more extended employment of the Natives not only as an a ct of justice but as a financial necessity." "The appointment of a few Natives annually to the Covenanted Civil Service will not solve the problem. . . . . If we are to govern the Indian people efficiently and cheaply, we must govern them by means of themselves, and pay for the Administration at the market rates of Native labour.'"*
"Any Inherent Defect."—Mr. Bright said† :—"I must say that it is my belief that if a country be found possessing a most fertile soil and capable of bearing every variety of production, and that notwithstanding the people are in a state of extreme destitution and suffering, the chances are there is some fundamental error in the government of that country."
I take an instance : Suppose a European servant draws a salary of Rs. 1,000 a month. He uses a portion of this for all his wants, of living, comfort, etc., etc. All this consumption by him is at the deprivation of an Indian who would and could, under right and natural circumstances, occupy that position and enjoy that provision. This is the first partial loss to India, as, at least, the services enjoyed by the Europeans are rendered by Indians as they would have rendered to any Indian occupying the position. But whatever the European sends to England for his various wants, and whatever savings and pension he ultimately, on his retirement, carries away with him, is a complete drain out of the country, crippling her whole material condition and her capacity to meet all her wants— a dead loss of wealth together with the loss of work and wisdom—i. e., the accumulated experience of his service. Besides, all State expenditure in this country is a dead loss to India.
This peculiar inherent evil or fundamental error in the present British Indian administration and management of expenditure and its consequences have been fortold more than a hundred years ago by Sir John Shore (1787):
"Whatever allowance we make for the increased industry of the subjects of the State, owing to the enhanced demand for the produce of it (supposing the demand to be enhanced), there is reason to conclude that the benefits are more than counterbalanced by evils inseparable from the system of a remote foreign dominion."*
And it is significantly remarkable that the same inherent evil in the present system of administration and management of expenditure has been, after nearly a hundred years, confirmed by a Secretary of State for India. Lord Randolph Churchill has said in a letter to the Treasury (1886)†:
"The position of India in relation to taxation and the sources of public revenue is very peculiar, not merely from the habits of the people and their strong aversion to change, which is more specially exhibited to new forms of taxation, but likewise from the character of the government, which is in the hands of foreigners who hold all the principle administrative offices and form so large a part of the Army. The impatience of the new taxation which will have to be borne wholly as a consequence of the foreign rule imposed on the country, and virtually to meet additions to charges arising outside of the country, would constitute a political danger the real magnitude of which it is to be feared is not at all appreciated by persons who have no knowledge of or concern in the government of India, but which those responsible for that government have long regarded as of the most serious order."
Lord Salisbury, as Secretary of State for India, put the same inherent evil in this manner: "The injury is exaggerated in the case of India, where so much of the revenue is exported without a direct equivalent." And he indicates the character of the present system of the administration and management of expenditure as being that "India must be bled."* I need not say more upon this aspect of the inherent evil of the present system of expenditure.
"The necessity or otherwise" of any expenditure is a necessary preliminary for its proper administration and management, so as to secure all I have indicated above. You incidentally instanced at the last meeting that all expenditure for the collection of revenue will have to be considered—and so, in fact, every expenditure in both countries will have its administration, management and necessity, to be considered.
The second part of the Reference is "The apportionment of charge between the Governments of the United Kingdom and of India for purposes in which both are interested."
What we shall have to do is, first to ascertain all the purposes in which both countries are interested by examining every charge in them, and how far each of them is respectively interested therein.
In my opinion there are some charges in which the United Kingdom is almost wholly or wholly interested. But any such cases will be dealt with as they arise.
After ascertaining such purposes and the extent of the interest of each country the next thing to do would be to ascertain the comparative capacity of each country, so as to fix the right apportionment according to such extent of interest and such capacity.
I shall just state here what has been already admitted to be the comparative capacity by high authorities. Lord Cromer (then Major Baring), as the Finance Minister of India, has said in his speech on the Budget (1882): “In England, the average income per head of population was £33; in France, it was £23; in Turkey, which was the poorest country in Europe, it was £4 per head.” I may add here that Mulhall gives for Russia above £9 per head. About India, Lord Cromer says: “It has been calculated that the average income per head of population in India is not more than Rs. 27 a year; and though I am not prepared to pledge myself to the absolute accuracy of a calculation of this sort, it is sufficiently accurate to justify the conclusion that the taxpaying community is exceedingly poor. To derive any very large increase of revenue from so poor a population as this is obviously impossible, and, if it were possible, would be unjustifiable.” “But he thought it was quite sufficient to show the extreme poverty of the mass of the people.” I think the principles of the calculation for India and the other countries are somewhat different; but that, if necessary, would be considered at the right time. For such large purposes with which the Commission has to deal these figures might be considered enough for guidance. I then asked Lord Cromer to give me the details of his calculations, as my calculations, which, I think, were the very first of their kind for India, had made out only Rs. 20 per head per annum. Though Rs. 27 or Rs. 20 can make but very small difference in the conclusion of “extreme poverty of the mass of the people,” still to those “extremely poor” people whose average is so small, and even that average cannot be available to every individual of them, the difference of so much as Rs. 7, or nearly 33 per cent., is a matter of much concern. Lord Cromer himself says : “He would ask honourable members to think what Rs. 27 per annum was to support a person, and then he would ask whether a few annas was nothing to such poor people.”
Unfortunately, Lord Cromer refused to give me his calculations. These calculations were, I am informed, prepared by Sir David Barbour, and the results embodied in a Note. I think the Commission ought to have this Note and details of calculations, and also similar calculations, say for the last five years or longer, to the latest day practicable. This will enable the Commission to form a definite opinion of the comparative capacity, as well as of any progress or otherwise in the condition of the people, and the average annual production of the country.
The only one other authority on the point of capacity which I would now give is that of Sir Henry Fowler as Secretary of State for India. He said* : “Now, as to the revenue, I think the figures are very instructive. Whereas in England the taxation is £2 11s. 8d. per head ; in Scotland, £2 8s. 1d. per head ; and in Ireland, £1 12s. 5d. per head ; the Budget which I shall present to-morrow will show that the taxation per head in India is something like 2s. 6d., or one-twentieth the taxation of the United Kingdom and one-thirteenth of that of Ireland.” And that this very small capacity of 2s. 6d. per head is most burdensome and oppressive is admitted on all hands, and the authorities are at their wits’ ends what to do to squeeze out more. So far back as 1870* Mr. Gladstone admitted about India as a country, “too much burdened,” and in 1893,† he said: “The expenditure of India and especially the Military expenditure is alarming.”
Sir David Barbour said‡: “The financial position of the Government of India at the present moment is such as to give cause for apprehension.” “The prospects of the future are disheartening.”§
Lord Landsdowne, as Viceroy, said‖: “We should be driven to lay before the Council so discouraging an account of our Finances, and to add the admission, that, for the present, it is beyond our power to describe the means by which we can hope to extricate ourselves from the difficulties and embarrassments which surround us.” “My hon. friend is, I am afraid, but too well justified in regarding our position with grave apprehension.” “We have to consider not so much the years which are past and gone as those which are immediately ahead of us, and if we look forward to these, there can be no doubt that we have cause for serious alarm.”¶
“Many such confessions can be quoted. And now when India is groaning under such intolerable heavy expenditure, and for the relief of which, indeed, this very Royal Commission has come into existence, the utmost that can be squeezed out of it to meet such expenditure is 2s. 6d. per head. Thus, by the statement of Sir H. Fowler as Secretary of State for India, the relative capacity of poor India at the utmost pressure is only one-twentieth of the capacity of the prosperous and wealthy United Kingdom. But there is still something worse. When the actual pressure of both taxations as compared, with the respective means of the two countries is considered, it will be found that the pressure of taxation on "extremely poor" India is much more heavy and oppressive than that on the most wealthy country of England.
Even admitting for the present the overestimate of Lord Cromer of Rs. 27 income, and the underestimate of Sir H. Fowler about 2s. 6d., revenue raised, the pressure of percentage of the Indian Revenue, as compared with India's means of paying, is even then slightly higher than that of the United Kingdom. But if my estimates of means and revenue be found correct, the Indian pressure or percentage will be found to be fifty or more per cent. heavier than that on the United Kingdom.
You have noticed a similar fallacy of regarding a smaller amount to be necessarily a lighter tax in the Irish Royal Commission.
"2613.* You went on to make rather a striking comparison between the weight of taxation in Ireland and Great Britain, and I think you took the years 1841 to 1881. In answer to Mr. Sexton, taking it head by head, the incidence of taxation was comparatively very light I may say in 1841, and very heavy comparatively in 1881?—Yes.
“2614. I would ask you does not that want some qualification. If you take alone without qualification the incidence of taxation upon people, leaving out of view entirely the fact whether the people have become in the interval poorer or richer, will you not get to a wrong conclusion? Let me give you an instance of what I mean. I will take such a place as the Colony of Victoria. Before the gold discoveries you had there a small, sparse, squatting population, probably very little administered, and paying very few taxes. Probably in such a case you would find out that the incidence of taxation at that time was extremely small?—Yes.
“2615. But take it thirty or forty years later when there was a greater population, and what I am now dwelling upon, an improvement in wealth, you would find out that the incidence of taxation was very much heavier per head; for instance, perhaps 5s. per head at first, and perhaps £2 in the second; but it would be wrong to draw the conclusion from that fact that the individuals were relatively more heavily taxed at the later period than the first. Would it not?”
Similarly, it would be wrong to draw the conclusion that the individuals of England were more heavily taxed than those of India, because the average of the former was £2 11s. 8d. and that of the latter was 2s. 6d. An elephant may carry a ton with ease, but an ant will be crushed by a quarter ounce.
Not only is India more heavily taxed than England to supply its expenditure, but there is another additional destructive circumstance against India. The whole British taxation of £2 11s. 8d. per head returns entirely to the people themselves from whom it is raised. But the 2s. 6d. so oppressively obtained out of the poverty-stricken Indians does not all return to them. No wonder that with such a destructive and unnatural system of " the administration and management of expenditure" millions perish by famine and scores of millions, or—as Lord Lawrence said (1864)— " the mass of the people, enjoy only a scanty subsistence." Again in 1873, before the Select Committee of the House of Commons, Lord Lawrence said: "The mass of the people of India are so miserably poor that they have barely the means of subsistence. It is as much as a man can do to feed his family or half-feed them, let alone spending money on what may be called luxuries or conveniences." I was present when this evidence was given, and I then noted down these words. I think they are omitted from the published report, I do not know why and by whom. In considering therefore the administration and management of expenditure and the apportionment of charge for common purposes, all such circumstances are most vital elements, the importance of the attention to which cannot be over-estimated.
The Times of 2nd July last, in its article on "Indian Affairs," estimates the extent and importance of the work of the Commission as follows :
"Great Britain is anxious to deal fairly with India. If it should appear that India has been saddled with charges which the British taxpayer should have borne, the British taxpayer will not hesitate to do his duty. At present we are in the unsatisfactory position which allows of injurious aspersions being made on the justice and good faith of the British nation, without having the means of knowing whether the accusations are true or false. Those accusations have been brought forward in the House of Lords, in the House of Commons, and in a hundred newspapers, pamphlets and memorials in India. Individual experts of equal authority take opposite sides in regard to them. Any curtailment of the scope of the Royal Commission's enquiry which might debar reasonable men from coming to a conclusion on these questions would be viewed with disappointment in England and with deep dissatisfaction throughout India."
Now, what are the "accusations" and "injurious aspersions" on the justice and good faith of the British nation? Here are some statements by high authorities as to the objects and results of the present system of the administration and management of expenditure of British Indian revenues.
Macaulay pointed out :
"That would indeed be a doting wisdom, which, in order that India might remain a dependency, would make it a useless and costly dependency--which would keep a hundred millions of men from being our customers in order that they might continue to be our slaves."*
Lord Salisbury says : "India must be bled."†
Mr. Bright said :
"The cultivators of the soil, the great body of the population of India, are in a condition of great impoverishment, of great dejection, and of great suffering."‡
"We must in future have India governed, not for a handful of Englishmen, not for that Civil Service whose praises are so constantly sounded in this House. You may govern India, if you like, for the good of England, but the good of England must come through the channels of the good of India. There are but two modes of gaining anything by our connexion with India. The one is by plundering the people of India, and the other by trading with them. I prefer to do it by trading with them. But in order that England may become rich by trading with India, India itself must become rich." §
Now, as long as the present system is what Mr. Bright characterises by implication as that of plundering, India cannot become rich.
"I say that a Government put over 250,000,000 of people, which has levied taxes till it can levy no more, which spends all that it can levy, and which has borrowed £100,000,000 more than all that it can levy—I say a Government like that has some fatal defect, which, at some not distant time, must bring disaster and humiliation to the Government and to the people on whose behalf it rules."*
Mr. Fawcett said :
"Lord Metcalf had well said that the bane of our system was that the advantages were reaped by one class and the work was done by another."†
Sir George Wingate‡ says with regard to the present system of expenditure :
"Taxes spent in the country from which they are raised are totally different in their effect from taxes raised in one country and spent in another. In the former case the taxes collected from the population . . . . are again returned to the industrious classes. . . . . But the case is wholly different when the taxes are not spent in the country from which they are raised. . . They constitute. . . . an absolute loss and extinction of the whole amount withdrawn from the taxed country . . . . might as well be thrown into the sea. . . . Such is the nature of the tribute we have so long exacted from India. . . . . From this explanation some faint conception may be formed of the cruel, crushing effect of the tribute upon India." "The Indian tribute, whether weighed in the scales of justice, or viewed in the light of our own interest, will be found to be at variance with humanity, with common sense, and with the received maxims of economic science."
Lord Lawrence, Lord Cromer, Sir Auckland Colvin and others declare the extreme poverty of British India, and that after a hundred years of the administration of expenditure by the most highly-praised and most highly-paid service in the world—by administrators drawn from the same class which serves in England.
Sir John Shore, as already stated, predicted a hundred years ago that under the present system the benefits are more than counterbalanced by its evils.
A Committee of five members § of the Council of the Secretary of State for India said, in 1860, that the British Government was exposed to the charge of keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope; and Lord Lytton* said, in 1878, the same, with greater emphasis, in a Minute which it is desirable the Commission should have.
Lord Lytton said †:
“The Act of Parliament is so undefined, and indefinite obligations on the part of the Government of India towards its Native subjects are so obviously dangerous, that no sooner was the Act passed than the Government began to devise means for practically evading the fulfilment of it. Under the terms of the Act, which are studied and laid to heart by that increasing class of educated Natives whose development the Government encourages without being able to satisfy the aspirations of its existing members, every such Native, if once admitted to Government employment in posts previously reserved to the covenanted service, is entitled to expect and claim appointment in the fair course of promotion to the highest post in that service. We all know that these claims and expectations never can or will be fulfilled. We have had to choose between prohibiting them and cheating them, and we have chosen the least straightforward course. The application to Natives of the competitive examination system—as conducted in England—and the recent reduction in the age at which candidates can compete are also many deliberate and transparent subterfuges for stultifying the Act, and reducing it to a dead letter. Since I am writing confidentially, I do not hesitate to say that both the Governments of England and of India appear to me, up to the present moment, unable to answer satisfactorily the charge of having taken every means in their power of breaking to the heart the words of promise they had uttered to the ear.”
The Duke of Argyll said ‡ :
“I must say that we have not fulfilled our duty or the promises and engagements which we have made.”
When Lord Northbrook pleaded § (1883) the Act of Parliament of 1833, the Court of Directors’ explanatory despatch and the great and solemn Proclamation of 1858, Lord Salisbury in reply said: "My lords, I do not see what is the use of all this political hypocrisy."*
The Act for which Macaulay said: "I must say that to the last day of my life I shall be proud of having been one of those who assisted in the framing of the Bill which contains that clause;" the clause which he called "that wise, that benevolent, that noble clause," and which Lord Lansdowne supported in a noble speech as involving "the happiness or misery of 100,000,000 of human beings," and as "confident that the strength of the Government would be increased;" and the great and most solemn proclamation of the Sovereign on behalf of the British nation are, according to Lord Salisbury, "political hypocrisy!" Can there be a more serious and injurious aspersion on the justice and good faith of the British nation?
The Duke of Devonshire pointed out that it would not be wise to tell a patriotic Native that the Indians shall never have any chance "except by their getting rid in the first instance of their European rulers."†
From the beginning of British connexion with India up to the present day India has been made to pay for every possible kind of expenditure for the acquisition and maintenance of British rule, and Britain has never contributed her fair share (except a small portion on few rare occasions, such as the last Afghan War) for all the great benefits it has always derived from all such expenditure and "bleeding" or "slaving" of India. And so this is a part of the important mission of this Commission, to justly apportion charge for purposes in which both countries are interested.
Such are some of the "accusations" and "injurious aspersions being made on the justice and good faith of the British nation," while truly "Great Britain is anxious to deal fairly with India." Justly does the Times conclude that "any curtailment of the scope of the Royal Commission's enquiry which might debar reasonable men from coming to a conclusion on these questions would be viewed with disappointment in England and with deep dissatisfaction throughout India."
The Times is further justified when Sir Henry Fowler himself complained of "a very strong indictment of the British government of India" having been "brought before the House and the country."* And it is this indictment which has led to the enquiry.
On the 10th of this month the Times, in a leader on the conduct of the Transvaal with regard to trade and franchise, ends in these words: "A man may suffer the restriction of his liberty with patience for the advancement of his material prosperity. He may sacrifice material prosperity for the sake of a liberty which he holds more valuable. When his public rights and his private interests are alike attacked the restraining influences on which the peace of civilised societies depends are dangerously weakened."
So, when the Indian finds that the present administration and management of expenditure sacrifice his material prosperity, that he has no voice in the administration and management of the expenditure of his country, and that every burden is put upon his head alone—when thus both "his public rights and private interests are alike attacked the restraining influences on which the peace of civilised societies depends are dangerously weakened."
Sir Louis Mallet ends his Minute of 3rd February, 1875, on Indian Land Revenue with words which deserve attention as particularly applicable to the administration, management, and necessity of Indian expenditure.* He says :
By a perpetual interference with the operation of laws which our own rule in India has set in motion, and which I venture to think are essential to success—by a constant habit of palliating symptoms instead of grappling with disease—may we not be leaving to those who come after a task so aggravated by our neglect or timidity that what is difficult for us may be impossible for them ?
I understand that every witness that comes before the Commission will not be considered as of any party, or to support this or that side, but as a witness of the Commission coming for the simple object of helping the Commission in finding out the actual whole truth of every question under consideration.
I shall esteem it a favour if, at the next meeting, you will be so good as to place this letter before the Commission. I may mention that I am sending a copy to every member of the Commission, in order that they may be made acquainted beforehand with its contents.
Yours truly,
Dadabhai Naoroji.
II.
Dear Lord Welby,—I now submit to the Commission a further representation* upon the most important test of the present "Administration and Management of Expenditure," viz., its results.
Kindly oblige me by laying it before the Commission at the next meeting. I shall send a copy of it to every member of the Commission. As the reference to the Commission embraces a number of most vital questions—vital both to England and India—I am obliged to submit my representation in parts. When I have finished I shall be willing, if the Commission think it necessary, to appear as a witness to be cross-examined upon my representations. If the Commission think that I should be examined on each of my representations separately, I shall be willing to be examined.
In the Act of 1858 (see. LIII) Parliament provided that among other information for its guidance the Indian authorities should lay before it every year "A Statement prepared from detailed Reports from each Presidency and District in India, in such form as shall best exhibit the Moral and Material Progress and Condition of India in each such Presidency." Thereupon such Reports were ordered by the Government of India to be prepared by the Government of each Presidency.
As a beginning the Reports were naturally imperfect in details. In 1862, the Government of India observed : "There is a mass of statistics in the Administration Reports of the various Local Governments . . . . but they are not compiled on any uniform plan . . . . so as to show the statistics of the Empire " (Fin. Con., June, '62). The Statistical Committee, which the Government of India had organised for the purpose, prepared certain Forms of Tables, and after receiving reports on those forms from the different Governments made a Report to the Government of India, with revised Forms of Tables (Office Memorandum, Financial Department, No. 1,043, dated 28/2/66). The members of this Committee were Mr. A. Grote, president, and Messrs. G. Campbell, D. Cowie, and G. Smith.
I confine myself in this statement to the tables concerning only the material condition of India, or what are called "Production and Distribution."
The following are the tables prescribed:—
PRODUCTION AND DISTRIBUTION.
FORM D.—Agriculture.
Under a former Section provision is made for information regarding soils so far as nature is concerned, and we have now to do with what the soil produces, and with all that is necessary to till the soil, all of which is embraced under the heads—Crop, Stock, Rent, and Production.
| Name of District | Rice | Wheat | Other Food Grains | Oil Seeds | Sugar | Cotton | Opium | Indigo | Fibres | Tobacco | Tea | Coffee | Vegetables, &c., &c. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total |
Stock.—2.
| District | Cows and Buffaloes | Horses | Ponies | Donkeys | Sheep and Goats | Pigs | Carts | Ploughs | Boats |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total |
Rates of Rent and Produce.—3.
| District | Rice | Wheat | Inferior Grains | Indigo | Cotton | Opium | Oil Seeds | Fibres | Sugar | Tobacco |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| General Average |
| District | Rice | Wheat | Inferior Food Grains | Indigo | Cotton | Opium | Oil Seeds | Fibres | Sugar | Tobacco | Tea | Coffee, &c., &c. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| General Average |
FORM E.
Produce.—1.
| District | Rice | Wheat | Linseed | Jute | Cotton | Sugar | Salt | &c., &c. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| General Average |
Plough Bullocks each — Wages per diem. — Cart per day — Sheep each — District — Skilled — Unskilled — Camel per day — Donkeys per score per day — Boat per ditto — Fish per seer — Iron per maund, &c., &c. — General average
FORM F.
Mines and Quarries.
Where Situated — Mineral Produced — Number of Mines — Annual Produce — Remarks
FORM G.—MANUFACTURES.
| CLASS OF MANUFACTURES. | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silk | Cotton | Wool | Other Fibres | Paper | Wood | Iron | Brass and Copper | Building, &c., &c. | |
| Number of Mills and Manufactories... | |||||||||
| Private Looms or Small Works ... | |||||||||
| Number of Workmen in Large Works: { Female... | |||||||||
| Male ... | |||||||||
| Number of Workmen in Small Works or Independent Artizans ... ... ... | |||||||||
| Number of European Superintendents in Large Works ... ... ... ... | |||||||||
| Value of block in ditto ... ... ... | |||||||||
| Estimated Annual Outturn of all Works ... | |||||||||
| Total... | |||||||||
It will be seen from these tables that they are sufficient for calculating the total “production” of any province, with such additions for sundry other produce as may be necessary, with sufficient approximacy to accuracy, to supply the information which Parliament wants to know about the progress or deterioration of the material condition of India.
Sir David Barbour said, in reply to a question put by Sir James Peile:—
“2283. It does not by any means follow that people are starving because they are poor?—Not in the least. You must recollect that the cost of the necessaries of life is very much less in India than it is in England.”
Now, the question is, whether, even with this “very much less cost” of the necessaries and wants of life, these necessaries and wants of life even to an absolute amount, few as they are, are supplied by the “production of the year.” Sir D. Barbour and others that speak on this point have not given any proof that even these cheap and few wants are supplied, with also a fair reserve for bad seasons. It is inexplicable why the Statistical Committee failed to prescribe the tables for the necessary consumption—or, as the heading of Form D. called “Distribution”—if they really meant to give Parliament such full information as to enable it to judge whether “the mass of the people,” as Lord Lawrence said, “lived on scanty subsistence” or not. The Statistical Committee has thus missed to ask this other necessary information, viz., the wants of a common labourer to keep himself and his family in ordinary, healthy working condition—in food, clothing, shelter, and other necessary ordinary social wants. It is by the comparison of what is produced and what is needed by the people even for the absolute necessaries of life (leave alone any luxuries) that anything like a fair idea of the condition of the people can be formed. In my first letter to the Secretary of State for India, of 24th May, 1880, I have worked out as an illustration all the necessary tables both for “production” and “distribution,” i.e., absolute necessaries of life of a common labourer in Punjab.
If the demands of Parliament are to be loyally supplied (which, unfortunately, is almost invariably not the attitude of Indian authorities in matters concerning the welfare of the Indians and honour of the British name depending thereon) there is no reason whatever why the information required is not fully furnished by every province. They have all the necessary materials for these tables, and they can easily supply the tables both for “production” and “distribution” or necessary consumption, at the prices of the year of all necessary wants. Then the Statistical Department ought to work up the average per head per annum for the whole of India of both “production” and “distribution.” Unless such information is supplied, it is idle and useless to endeavour to persuade the Commission that the material condition of the people of British India is improving. It was said in the letter of the Secretary of State for India to me of 9th August, 1880, that in Bengal means did not exist of supplying the information I desired. Now that may have been the case in 1880, but it is not so now; and I cannot understand why the Bengal Government does not give the tables of production at all in its Administration Report. The only table, and that the most important one, for which it was said they had not the means, and which was not given in the Administration Report, is given in detail in the “Statistical Abstract of British India for 1893-4” (Parl. Ret. [C. 7,887] 1895), pp. 141-2.
| Rice. | Wheat. | Other Food Grains (including Pulses). | Other Food Crops. | Sugar Cane. | Coffee. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 38,200,300 | 1,620,200 | 11,636,000 | 3,130,900 | 1,083,400 | ...... |
| Tea. | Cotton. | Jute. | Other Fibres. | Oil Seeds. | Indigo. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 110,800 | 201,280 | 2,228,200 | 207,100 | 3,253,000 | 614,200 |
| Tobacco. | Cinchona. | Miscellaneous. | Total area under crops. | Deduct area cropped more than once. | Actual area on which crops were grown. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 730,500 | 2,900 | 424,900 | 64,444,200 | 10,456,900 | 53,987,300 |
Then, at page 142, there is also given total area under crops—of area under irrigation—64,444,200 acres. Certainly, if they can know the total area, they can ascertain the average of some of the principal crops. Then as to the crops per acre of some of the principal produce, they can have no difficulty in ascertaining, and the prices are all regularly published of principal articles of food. There can be no difficulty in obtaining the prices of all principal produce. The whole matter is too important to be so lightly treated. The extreme importance of this information can be seen from the fact that Parliament has demanded it by an Act, and that Sir Henry Fowler himself made a special and earnest challenge about the condition of the people. He said in his speech on 15th August, 1894, when he promised the Select Committee :—
“The question I wish to consider is whether that Government, with all its machinery as now existing in India, has or has not promoted the general prosperity of the people in its charge ; and whether India is better or worse off by being a Province of the British Crown.”
And this is the question to which an answer has to be given by this Commission—whether the present administration and management of the Military and Civil Expenditure incurred in both countries, “ has or has not,” as one of its results, “ promoted the general prosperity of the people ” of British India. Or is, or is not, the result of this administration and management of expenditure “ scanty subsistence” for the mass of the people as admitted by Lord Lawrence, and “ extreme proverty ” as stated by Lord Cromer, Sir Auckland Colvin, and Sir David Barbour among the latest Finance Ministers—a poverty compared with which even the most oppressed and misgoverned Russia is prosperity itself, the income of which is given by Mulhall as above £9 per head per annum, which Lord Cromer gives the income of British India as “ not more than Rs. 27 per head per annum,” and I calculate it as not more than Rs. 20 per head per annum. Even this wretched income, insufficient as it is, is not all enjoyed by the people, but a portion never returns to them, thereby continuously though gradually diminishing their individual capacity for production. Surely, there cannot be a more important issue before the Commission as to the results of the administration and management of expenditure, as much or even more for the sake of Britain itself than for that of India.
Before proceeding further on the subject of these statistics it is important to consider the matter of the few wants of the Indian in an important aspect. Is the few wants a reason that the people should not prosper, should not have better human wants and better human enjoyments? Is that a reason that they ought not to produce as much wealth as the British are producing here? Once the Britons were wandering in the forests of this country, and their wants were few; had they remained so for ever what would Britain have been to-day? Has not British wealth grown a hundred times, as Macaulay has said? And is it not a great condemnation of the present British administration of Indian expenditure that the people of India cannot make any wealth—worse than that, they must die off by millions, and be underfed by scores of millions, produce a wretched produce, and of that even somebody else must deprive them of a portion!
The British first take away their means, incapacitate them from producing more, compel them to reduce their wants to the wretched means that are left to them, and then turn round upon them and, adding insult to injury, tell them: “See, you have few wants; you must remain poor and of few wants. Have your pound of rice—or, more generously, we would allow you two pounds of rice— scanty clothing and shelter. It is we who must have and would have great human wants and human enjoyments, and you must slave and drudge for us like mere animals, as our beasts of burden.” Is it that the mass of the Indians have no right or business to have any advancement in civilisation, in life and life’s enjoyments, physical, moral, mental and social? Must they always live to the brute’s level—must have no social expenses—is that all extravagance, stupidity, want of intelligence, and what not? Is it seriously held, in the words of Lord Salisbury: “They (the Natives of India) know perfectly well that they are governed by a superior race” (Hansard, vol. 277, 9/4/83, page 1,798), and that that superior race should be the masters, and the Indians the slaves and beasts of burden? Why the British-Indian authorities and Anglo-Indians generally (of course with honourable and wise exceptions) do every mortal thing to disillusion the Indians of the idea of any superiority by open violation and dishonour of the most solemn-pledges, by subtle bleeding of the country, and by obstructing at every point any step desired by the British people for the welfare of the Indians. I do hope, as I do believe, that both the conscience and the aspiration of the British people, their mission and charge, which it is often said Providence has placed in their hands, are to raise the Indians to their own level of civilisation and prosperity, and not to degrade themselves to the lowness of Oriental despotism and the Indians to mere helots.
I may here again point out some defects in these statistics so as to make them as accurate as they can possibly be made, in supplying the Commission with the necessary information. It is surprising that Indian highly-paid civilians should not understand the simple arithmetic of averages; and that they should not correct the mistake even after the Secretary of State for India forwarded my letter pointing out the mistake.
The mistake is this. Supposing the price of rice in one district is Re. 1 per maund, and in another district Rs. 3 per maund, then the average is taken by simply adding 3 and 1 and dividing by 2, making it to be Rs. 2 per maund, forgetting altogether to take into account the quantities sold at Rs. 3 and Re. 1 respectively. Supposing the quantity sold at Re. 1 per maund is 1,000,000 maunds and that sold at Rs. 3 is only 50,000 maunds, then the correct average will be :—
| Maunds. | Rs. | Rs. | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1,000,000 | × 1 = | 1,000,000 | |
| 50,000 | × 3 = | 150,000 | |
| Total ... | 1,050,000 | 1,150,000 |
which will give Re. 1 1 an. 6 pies per maund, instead of the incorrect Rs. 2 per maund, as is made out by simply adding 1 and 3 and dividing by 2.
In my “Poverty of India” I have given an actual illustration (supra pp. 3-4). The average price of rice in the Administration Report of the Central Provinces for 1867-8 was made out to be, by the wrong method, Rs. 2 12 an. 7 pies, while the correct price was only Rs. 1 8 an. Also the correct average of produce was actually 759 lbs. per acre, when it was incorrectly made out to be 579 lbs. per acre. Certainly there is no excuse for such arithmetical mistakes in information required by Parliament for the most important purpose of ascertaining the result of the British Administration of the expenditure of a vast country.
In the same way averages are taken of wages without considering how many earn the different wages of 1½, 2, 3 or more annas per day and for how many days in the year.
In the Irish Commission you yourself and the Chairman have noticed this fallacy.
Witness, Dr. T. W. Grimshaw.
Question 2925. (Lord Welby): Do you take a mean price?—I take a mean price between highest and lowest.
2926. (Chairman): An arithmetical mean price without reference to the quantities ?—Yes.
2927. (Lord Welby): For instance, supposing for nine months there had been a low price, and the remaining three a high price, the mean would hardly represent a real mean, would it?— You are correct in a certain sense. . . . .
Trade.—Totals are taken of both imports and exports together and any increase in these totals is pointed out as proof of a flourishing trade and increasing benefit when in reality it is no such thing, but quite the reverse altogether. I shall explain what I mean.
Suppose a merchant sends out goods to a foreign country which have cost him £1,000. He naturally expects to get back the £1,000 and some profit, say 15 per cent. ; i. e., he expects to receive back £1,150. This will be all right ; and suppose he sends out more, say £2,000 worth, the next year and gets back his £2,300, then it is really an increasing and profitable trade. But suppose a merchant sent out goods worth £1,000 and gets back £800 instead of £1,150 or anything above £1,000; and again the second year he sent £2,000 worth and got back £1,600. To say that such a trade is a flourishing or profitable trade is simply absurd. To say that because the total of the exports and imports of the first year was £1,800, and the total of the exports and imports in the second year was £3,600, that therefore it was a cause for rejoicing, when in reality it is simply a straight way to bankruptcy with a loss of £200 the first year, and £400 the second year (leaving alone profits), and so on. Such is the condition of British India. Instead of getting back its exports with some profit, it does not get back even equal to the exports themselves, but a great deal less every year. Why then, it may be asked, does India not go into bankruptcy as any merchant would inevitably go? And the reason is very simple. The ordinary merchant has no power to put his hand in other persons' pockets, and make up his losses. But the despotic Government of India, on the one hand, goes on inflicting on India unceasing losses and drain by its unnatural administration and management of expenditure, and, on the other hand, has the power of putting its hands unhindered into the pockets of the poor taxpayer and make its account square.
While the real and principal cause of the sufferings and poverty of India is the deprivation and drain of its resources by foreigners by the present system of expenditure, the Anglo-Indians generally, instead of manfully looking this evil in the face, ignore it and endeavour to find all sorts of other excuses. It is very necessary that the Commission should have the opportunity of fairly considering those excuses. Now, one way I can deal with them would be for myself to lay them down as I understand them; or, which is far better, I should deal with them as they are actually put forth by some high Anglo-Indian official. As I am in a position to do so, I adopt the second course. A high official of the position of an Under-Secretary of State for India and Governor of Madras, Sir Grant Duff, has already focussed all the official reasons in two papers he contributed to the Contemporary Review, and I have answered them in the same Review in 1887. I cannot therefore do better than to embody my reply here, omitting from it all personal remarks or others irrelevant to the present purpose. In connexion with my reply, I may explain here that it is because I have taken in it £1 = Rs. 10 that the incidence of taxation is set down as 6s. per head per annum, while Sir H. Fowler's estimate is only 2s. 6d. per head at the present depressed exchange and excluding land revenue. Sir H. Fowler excludes land revenue from the incidence as if land revenue, by being called "rent," rained from heaven, and was not raised as much from the production of the country as any other part of the revenue. The fact of the matter is that in British India as in every other country, a certain portion of the production of the country is taken by the State, under a variety of names—land tax or rent, salt revenue, excise, opium, stamps, customs, assessed taxes, post office surplus, law and justice surplus, etc., etc. In some shape or other so much is taken from the production, and which forms the incidence of taxation. The evil which India suffers from is not in what is raised or taken from the "production" and what India, under natural administration, would be able to give two or three times over, but it is in the manner in which that revenue is spent under the present unnatural administration and management of expenditure whereby there is an unceasing "bleeding" of the country.
My reply to Sir Grant Duff was made in 1887. This brings some of the figures to a later date than my correspondence with the Secretary of State for India. Singlehanded I have not the time to work out figures to date, but I shall add afterwards some figures which I have already worked out for later than 1887. I give below my reply to Sir Grant Duff as I have already indicated above.
All the subjects treated in the following extracts are the direct consequences of the present system of “ the administration and management of expenditure in both countries.” It is from this point of view that I give these extracts. (See my reply, in August and November, 1887, to Sir Grant Duff, supra, pp. 231-272.)
I give below some of the latest figures I already have to compare the results of the administration of expenditure in India with those of other parts of the British Empire.
Ten Years (1883-1892).
| Countries. | Imports (in- cluding Gold and Silver.) | Exports (in- cluding Gold and Silver). | Excess of Im- ports over Exports. | Per- cent- age of Trade Profits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| £ | £ | £ | ||
| United Kingdom... (Par. Ret. [C. 7,143] 1893.) | 4,247,954,247 | 3,203,603,246 | 1,044,351,001 | 32 |
| Australasia ... | 643,462,379 | 582,264,839 | 61,197,540 | 10·5* |
| North American Colonies ... | 254,963,473 | 205,063,294 | 49,900,179 | 24·4 |
| Straits Settlements (Par. Ret. [C. 7,144] 1893.) | 204,613,643 | 181,781,667 | 22,831,976 | 12·5 |
Cape of Good Hope and Natal. I cannot give figures as the gold brought into the Colonies from Transvaal is not included in the imports; while exports include gold and silver.
Natal. In this also goods in transit are not included in imports, although included in exports.
British India. Far from any excess of imports or trade profits, there is, as will be seen further on, actually a large deficit in imports (Rx. 774,099,570) from the actual exports (Rx. 944,279,318). Deficit from its own produce (Rx. 170,179,748)—18 per cent.
India.
Particulars of the Trade of India and the losses of the Indian people of British India ; or, The Drain.
| India's total Exports, including Treasure. Rx. 944,279,318 | |
| „ 188,855,863 | Add, as in other countries, say 20 per cent. excess of imports or profits (U.K. is 32 per cent.) |
| Rx. 1,133,135,181 | or the amount which the imports should be. |
| But | |
| „ 774,099,570 | only are the actual imports. |
| Rx. 359,035,611 | is the loss of India for which it has not received back a single farthing either in Merchandise or treasure. |
Now, the question is what has become of this Rx. 359,000,000 which India ought to have received but has not received.
This amount includes the payment of interest on railway and other public works loans.
Owing to our impoverishment, our utter helplessness, subjection to a despotism without any voice in the administration of our expenditure, our inability to make any capital, and therefore, forced to submit to be exploited by foreign capital, every farthing of the above amount is a loss and a drain to British India. We have no choice ; the whole position is compulsory upon us. It is no simple matter of business to us. It is all simply the result of the despotic administration of expenditure of our resources.
Still, however, let us consider these loans as a matter of business, and see what deduction we should make from the above amount.
The loans for public works during the ten years (Par. Ret. [c. 7193] 1893, p. 298) are :—Rx. 34,350,000 (this is taken as Rs. 10 = £1—p. 130), or £34,350,000. This amount is received by India, and forms a part of its imports.
The interest paid during the ten years in England is £57,700,000. This amount, being paid by India, forms a part of its exports. The account, then, will stand thus :—
India received or imported as loans £ 34,350,000 in the ten years. India paid or exported as interest £57,700,000, leaving an excess of exports as a business balance £23,350,000, or, say, at average 1s. 4d. per rupee, Rx. 37,360,000.
This export made by India in settlement of public works loans interest account may be deducted from the above unaccounted amount of Rx. 359,000,000, leaving a balance of Rx. 321,640,000 still unreceived by India.
The next item to be considered is public debt (other than for public works). This debt is not a business debt in any possible way. It is simply the political burden put upon India by force for the very acquisition and maintenance of the British rule. It is entirely owing to the evil administration of expenditure in putting every burden on India. Make an allowance for even this forced tribute.
The public debt of India (excluding public works) incurred during the ten years is £ 16,000,000, (p. 298), of which, say, £8,000,000 has interest to be paid in London. (I do not know how much is raised in India and how much in England. I think I asked the India Office for this, but it is difficult to get definite information from it.) The interest paid in London during the ten years is £28,600,000. This forms part of the exports of India. The £8,000,000 of the debt incurred during the ten years form part of the imports of India, leaving a balance of, say, £21,000,000. On public debt account to be further deducted from the last balance of unaccounted loss of Rx. 321,640,000, taking, £21,000,000 at 1s. 4d. per rupee will give about Rx. 33,000,000, which, deducted from Rx. 321,640,000, will still leave the unaccounted loss or drain of Rx. 288,000,000. I repeat that as far as the economic effect on India of the despotic administration and management of expenditure under the British rule is concerned, the whole amount of Rx. 359,000,000 is a drain from the wretched resources of India.
But to avoid controversy, allowing for all public debt (political and commercial), there is still a clear loss or drain of Rx. 288,000,000 in ten years, with a debt of £210,000,000 hanging round her neck besides.
Rx. 288,000,000 is made up of Rx. 170,000,000 from the very blood or produce of the country itself, and Rx. 118,000,000 from the profits of trade.
It must be also remembered that freight, insurance, and other charges after shipment are not calculated in the exports from India, every farthing of which is taken by England. When these items are added to the exports the actual loss to British India will be much larger than the above calculations. I may also explain that the item of stores is accounted for in the above calculations. The exports include payment for these stores, and imports include the stores. The whole of the above loss and burden of debt has to be borne by only the Indian taxpayers of British India. The Native States and their capitalists, bankers, merchants, or manufacturers, and the European capitalists, merchants, bankers, or manufacturers get back their full profits.
In the above calculation I have taken 20 per cent. as what ought to be the excess of imports under natural circumstances, just as the excess of the United Kingdom is 32 per cent. But suppose I take even 15 per cent. instead of 20 per cent., then the excess of imports would be, say, Rx. 311,000,000 instead of nearly Rx. 359,000,000. From this Rx. 311,000,000, deduct, as above, Rx. 37,000,000 for public works account and Rx. 33,000,000 for political public debt account, there will still be a loss or drain of Rx. 241,000,000 in ten years.
Strictly considered in India's helpless condition, there has been a drain of its wealth to the extent of Rx. 360,000,000 in the ten years.
But, as I have said, to avoid all futile controversy, after allowing fully for all debt, there is still a drain of Rx. 241,000,000 or Rx. 24,000,000 a year during the ten years.
But it must be also remembered that besides the whole of the above drain, either Rx. 359,000,000, or Rx. 241,000,000, there is also the further loss of all that is consumed in India itself by foreigners so far, to the deprivation and exclusion of the children of British India.
Now, let it be once more understood that there can be no objection to any capitalist, or banker, or merchant, or manufacturer going to India on his own account and making any profits there, if we are also left free to do our best in fair competition, but as long as we are impoverished and made utterly helpless in our economic condition by the forced and unnatural present system of the administration and management of expenditure, the whole profits of foreigners (European or Indian) is British India's irreparable loss.
The moral, therefore, of this phenomenon is that Sir John Shore's prediction of 1787, about the evil effect of foreign domination by the adoption of the present system of the administration and management of expenditure, is amply and deplorably fulfilled. Truly has Macaulay said: "The heaviest of all yokes is the yoke of the stranger." It cannot be otherwise under the existing administration and management of expenditure. What an enormous sum, almost beyond calculation, would British India's loss amount to in the present century (leaving alone the last century of unparalleled corruption, plunder, and oppression by Europeans) when calculated with compound interest! A tremendously "cruel and crushing" and destructive tribute indeed!
With regard to the allegation that the fall in exchange has stimulated exports from India, here are a few figures which tell their own tale :—
| Exports in 1870-1. | Rx. 64,690,000 |
| " " 1890-1. | Rx. 102,340,000 |
or an increase of about 60 per cent. This is the increase in the 20 years of the fall of exchange.
| Now take 1850, exports. | £18,700,000 |
| ,, ,, 1870, ,, | £64,690,000 |
i.e., an increase of nearly 3½ times. Was this increase owing to fall in Exchange? There was then no such fall in Exchange. And what good was this increase to India ? As shown above, in ten years only she has been drained to the extent indicated, besides what is eaten in the country by those who are not her children. The increase in trade, excepting that of Native and Frontier States, is not natural and economic for the benefit of the people of British India. It is mostly only the form in which the increasing crushing tribute and the trade-profits and wants of foreigners are provided by the poor people of British India, the masses of whom live on scanty subsistence, and are ill-fed, ill-clothed, and ill-habited hewers of wood and drawers of water for them.
But there is another most important consideration still remaining.
While British India is thus crushed by a heavy tribute which is exacted by the upper classes and which must end in disaster, do the British industrial people, or the great mass, derive such benefit as they ought to derive, with far greater benefit to England itself, besides benefitting India?
Here is this wretched result so far as the producers of British and Irish produce are concerned, or the British trade with India is concerned.
In 1893, all British and Irish produce exported to all India is only £28,800,000 for a population of 285,000,000 or 2s. per head per annum. But a large portion of this goes to the Native States and frontier territories. British Indian subjects themselves (221,000,000) will be found to take hardly a shilling or fifteen pence worth per head per annum. And this is all that the British people export to British India. If British India were more righteously treated and allowed to prosper, British produce will be exported to British India as much or a great deal more than what the British people are exporting to the whole world. A word to our Lancashire friends. If they would open their eyes to their true interests, and give up squabbling about these wretched cotton duties, they would see that a market of 220,000,000 people of British India, besides the 64,000,000 of the Native States, will require and take (if you take your hand off their throat), more than Lancashire will be able to supply. Look at the wretched Lancashire trade with the poverty-stricken British Indians :—
In 1892-3 India imported yarn £ 2,683,850 — = £25,625,865. Manufactures £22,942,015 }
for a population of 285,000,000, or about 1s. 9d. per head per annum. But if you deduct Native States and Frontier States, it will possibly be 1s. per head for British India. Why should it not be even £1 or more per head if British India be not "bled"? And Lancashire may have £250,000,000 or more of trade instead of the wretched £25,000,000. Will Lancashire ever open its eyes and help both itself and India to be prosperous?
Argument of Population.
Increase from 1881 to 1891 :—
| Increase. | Population per Square Mile. | |
|---|---|---|
| England and Wales . . | 11·6 per cent. | . 500 |
| British India . . . | 9·7 „ | . 230 |
In 1801, the population of England and Wales (Mulhall's Dictionary, p. 444) was 8,893,000, say 9,000,000.
In 1884, the population was 27,000,000 (Parl. Ret. [c. 7,143], 1893), or three times as much as in 1801.
The income of England and Wales (Mul., p. 320) in 1800 was £230,000,000.
In 1884, while the population increased to 27,000,000 or three times that of 1801, the income increased to £976,000,000 (Mul., p. 321), or nearly 4¼ times that of 1800.
The population of England and Wales (Mul. p. 444) in 1672, was 5,500,000. The income in 1664 (Mul., p., 320) was £42,000,000.
In 1884, (Mul., p. 321), population 27,000,000, increased five times; income £976,000,000, increased more than twenty-three times.
As comparison with earlier times Macaulay said (supra, p. 269) : "While our numbers have increased tenfold, our wealth has increased hundredfold."
These facts do not show that increase of population has made England poorer. On the contrary, Macaulay truly says "that the advantages arising from the progress of civilisation have far more than counterbalanced the disadavantages arising from the progress of population."
Why, then, under the administration of the "greatest" and most highly-paid service in the world, derived from the same stock as the administrators of this country, and, as Mr. Bright says, "whose praises are so constantly sounded in this House," is India, after a long period at period, at present the most "extremely poor" country in the world? And yet how can the result be otherwise under the existing administration and management of expenditure, based upon the evil principle that "India must be bled"? The fault is not of the officials. It is the evil and outrageous system of expenditure, which cannot but produce such pernicious and deplorable results, which, if not remedied in time, must inevitably bring about a retribution the extent and disaster of which can hardly be conceived. Officials over and over again tell us that the resources of India are boundless. All the resources of civilisation have been at their command, and here is this wretched and ignominious result—that while England has gone on increasing in wealth at a greater progress than in population, India at this moment is far poorer than even the misgoverned and oppressed Russia, and poorer even than Turkey in its annual production, as Lord Cromer pointed out in 1882.
I think I need not say anything more upon the first part of our Reference. If I am required to be cross-examined on the representations which I have submitted, I shall then say whatever more may be necessary for me to say.
I have shown, by high authorities and by facts and figures, one result of the existing system of "The administration and management of the Military and Civil Expenditure incurred under the authority of the Secretary of State for India in Council, or of the Government of India"—viz., the most deplorable evil of the extreme poverty of the mass of the people of British India—suicidal and dishonourable to British name and rule, and destructive and degrading to the people of British India, with a "helot system" of administration instead of that of British citizenship.
The following remarks in a leader of the Times of 16th December, 1895, in connexion with the Transvaal, is, short of compulsory service, applicable with ten times more force to the British rule of British India. The Times says :—
"The time is past even in South Africa when a helot system of administration organised for the exclusive advantage of a privileged minority can long resist the force of enlightened public opinion. If President Kruger really possesses any of those statesmanlike qualities which are sometimes ascribed to him, he will hasten to accept the loyal co-operation of these Ouitlanders, who have already done so much and who are anxious to do more for the prosperity and progress of the South African Republic."
I would apply this to British India. The time is past in British India when a "helot system of administration," organised for the exclusive advantage of a privileged minority, and existing to the great dishonour of the British name for a century and a half, can long resist the force of enlightened public opinion, and the dissatisfaction of the people themselves. If the British statesmen of the present day possess those statesmanlike qualities which the statesmen of 1833 showed about India—to "be just and fear not," which the great Proclamation of 1858 proclaimed to the world, and which Sir H. Fowler so lately (3/9/'95) described as having "the courage of keeping our word"— they will hasten to accept the loyal co-operation of the people of India, with whose blood mainly, and with whose money entirely, has the British Indian Empire been both built up and maintained; from whom Britain has drawn thousands of millions, or untold wealth calculated with interest; who for British righteousness would return the most devoted and patriotic loyalty for their own sake, and whose prosperity and progress, as Lord Roberts said, being indissolubly bound up with those of Britain, would result in largely increasing the prosperity of the British people themselves, in the stability of the British rule and in the redemption of the honour and good name of Britain from the dishonour of many broken pledges. The deplorable evil result of the present "administration and management of expenditure," in violation of solemn pledges, is so subtle, so artistic, so unobservably "bleeding," to use Lord Salisbury's word, so plausibly masked with the face of beneficence, and being unaccompanied with any open compulsion or violence to person or property which the world can see and be horrified with, that, as the poet says :—
That see the smallest speck of distant pain,
While at their feet a world of agony,
Unseen, unheard, unheeded, writhes in vain."
—Great Thoughts, 31/8/'95.
Even a paper like the Pioneer of Allahabad (21/9/'95) which cannot be accused of being opposed to Anglo-Indian views, recognises that India "has also perhaps to undergo the often subtle disadvantages of foreign rule." Yes, it is these "subtle disadvantages of foreign rule" which need to be grappled with and removed, if the connexion between India and England is to be a blessing to both, instead of a curse. This is the great and noble task for our Commission. For, indeed, it would be wise to ponder whether and how far Lord Salisbury's—a statesman's— words at the last Lord Mayor's dinner, apply to British India. He said :—
"That above all treaties and above all combinations of external powers, 'the nature of things' if you please, or 'the providence of God,' if you please to put it so, has determined that persistent and constant misgovernment must lead the Government which follows it to its doom; and while I readily admit that it is quite possible for the Sultan of Turkey, if he will, to govern all his subjects in justice and in peace, he is not exempt, more than any other potentate from the law that injustice will bring the highest on earth to ruin."
The administration of expenditure should be based on this principle, as Sir Louis Mallet (c. 3086—1) 1881, p. 142, has said :—
“If India is to be maintained and rendered a permanent portion of the British Empire, this must be accomplished in some other way than by placing our future reliance on the empirical arts of despotism” and not on those low motives of making India as simply an exploiting ground for our “boys” as Sir C. Crossthwaite desired when he had the candour of expressing the motive of British action when speaking about Siam at the Society of Arts (vol. 39—19/2/’92—p. 286). All that gentleman cared for was this. “The real question was who was to get the trade with them and how we could make the most of them, so as to find fresh markets for our goods and also employment for those superfluous articles of the present day, our boys” (the italics are mine), as if the whole world was created simply for supplying markets to the one people, and employment to their boys. Still, however, you can have ten times more trade than you have at present with India, far more than you have at present with the whole world, if you act on lines of righteousness, and cast off the second mean motive to enslave other people to give employment to your “boys,” which certainly is not the motive of the British people. The short of the whole matter is, that under the present evil and unrighteous administration of Indian expenditure, the romance is the beneficence of the British rule, the reality is the “bleeding” of the British rule. Under a righteous “administration of expenditure,” the reality will be the blessing and benefit both to Britain and India, and far more trade between them than we can form any conception of at present.
Yours truly,
Dadabhai Naoroji.
Notes
- *. Submitted by Mr. Naoroji to the Welby Commission, October 1895.
- †. Speech in House of Commons, 3/6/1853.
- ‡. Ib., 23/8/83.
- §. “England's Work in India,” p. 131, 1880.
- *. House of Commons, 23/8/1883.
- †. "England's Work in India," p. 130.
- *. "England's Work in India," pp. 118-19.
- †. House of Commons, 3/6/1853.
- *. Parliamentary Return 377 of 1812. Minute, para 132.
- †. Par. Return [c.4868], 1886.
- *. Par. Return [c. 3086-1], 1881, p. 144. Minute, 29/4/75.
- *. Budget Debate, 15/8/94.
- *. Hansard, vol. 201, p. 521, 10/5/1870.
- †. Hansard, vol. 14, p. 622, 30/6/1893.
- ‡. Par. Return 207, of 1893, Financial Statement, 23/3/93.
- §. Ib., para. 28.
- ‖. Par. Return 207, of 1893. Financial Statement, 23/3/93.
- ¶. Par. Return 207, of 1893, p. 110. Financial Statement, 23/3/93.
- *. Par. Return [c. 7720-1], 1895. Lord Welby.
- *. Hansard, vol. 19, p. 533, 10/7/1833.
- †. Par. Return [c. 3086-1], 1881.
- ‡. House of Commons, 14/6/1858.
- §. House of Commons, 24/6/1858.
- *. Speech in the Manchester Town Hall, 11/12/1877.
- †. Hansard, vol. 191, p. 1841, 5/5/1868.
- ‡. "A Few Words on our Financial Relations with India." (London, Richardson Bros., 1859.)
- §. Sir J. P. Willoughby, Mr. Mangles, Mr. Arbuthnot, Mr. Mac-Naughton, Sir E. Perry.
- *. Report of the first Indian National Congress, p. 30.
- †. I believe this to be in a Minute 30/5/1878 (?) to which the Government of India’s Despatch of 2/5/1878 refers. Par. Return [C. 2376, 1870, p. 15].
- ‡. Speech in House of Lords, 11/3/1869.
- §. Hansard, vol. 277, p. 1792, 9/4/1883.
- *. Ib., p. 1798.
- †. House of Commons, 23/8/1883.
- *. House of Commons, 15/8/1894.
- *. Par. Return [c. 3086-1], 1881, p. 135.
- *. Submitted to the Welby Commission on 9th January 1896.
- Note. Note.—The general character of the staple of the district should be stated as “Cotton, Indigenous,” “Cotton, New Orleans,” “Sugar, Raw,” “Sugar, Refined,” “Salt, Rock,” “Salt, Samber Lake,” and so on.
- *. Australasia is a large gold and silver exporting country. Profits on this are a very small percentage. The profits on other produce or merchandise will be larger than 10·5 per cent., and it should also be borne in mind that Australasia, like India, is a borrowing country, and a portion of its exports, like that of India, goes for the payment of interest on foreign loans. Still, it not only pays all that interest from the profits of trade, but secures for itself also a balance of 10·5 per cent. profits, while India must not only lose all its profits of trade but also Rx. 170,000,000 of its own produce. Were India not “ bleeding ” politically it would also be in a similar condition of paying for its loans and securing something for itself out of the trade profits.