Dear Lord Welby,—I have to request you kindly to put before the Commission this further representation from me on the subjects of our enquiry. This will be my last letter, unless some phase of the enquiry needed any further explanation from me.
Looking at the first part of the enquiry from every point of view, with regard to the administration and management of expenditure, we come back again and again to the view expressed by the Duke of Devonshire and Sir William Hunter and others. The Duke of Devonshire has said: "If the country is to be better governed, that can only be done by the employment of the best and most intelligent of the Natives in the Service." Sir William Hunter has said: "But the good work thus commenced has assumed such dimensions, under the Queen's Government of India that it can no longer be carried on or even supervised by imported labour from England except at a cost which India cannot sustain. . . . If we are to govern the Indian people efficiently and cheaply, we must govern them by means of themselves, and pay for the administration at the market rates of Native labour."
From all I have said in my previous representations it must have been seen that the real evil and misery of the people of British India does not arise from the amount of expenditure. India is capable, under natural circumstances, of providing twice, three times or more the expenditure, as the improvement of the country may need, in attaining all necessary progress. The evil really is in the way in which that expenditure is administered and managed, with the effect of a large portion of that expenditure not returning to the people from whom it is raised—in short, as Lord Salisbury has correctly described as the process of "bleeding." No country in the world (England not excepted) can stand such bleeding. To stop this bleeding is the problem of the day—bleeding both moral and material. You may devise the most perfect plan or scheme of government, not only humanly but divinely perfect—you may have the foreign officials, the very angels themselves—but it will be no earthly good to the people as long as the bleeding management of expenditure continues the same. On the contrary, the evil will increase by the very perfection of such plan or scheme for improvements and progress. For, as improvements and progress are understood to mean, at present, it is more and more bleeding by introducing more and more the foreign bleeding agency.
The real problem before the Commission is not how to nibble at the expenditure and suggest some poor reductions here and there, to be put aside in a short time, as is always done, but how to stop the material and moral bleeding, and leaving British India a freedom of development and progress in prosperity which her extraordinary natural resources are capable of, and to treat her justly in her financial relations with Britain by apportioning fairly the charge on purposes in which both are interested. Or, to put the problem in its double important bearings, in the words of an eminent statesman, " which should at once afford a guarantee for the good government of the people, and for the security of British rights and interests " (Lord Iddesleigh), as will be seen further on. I am glad to put before the Commission that this problem has been not merely enunciated, but that, with the courage of their convictions, two eminent statesmen have actually carried it out practically, and have done that with remarkable success. I am the more glad to bring forward this case before the Commission, as it also enables me to adduce an episode in the British Indian administration on the conduct of the Indian authorities in both countries and other Anglo-Indian officials, which reflects great credit upon all concerned in it—and as my information goes, and as it also appears from the records, that her Majesty personally has not a little share in this praise, and in evoking a hearty Indian gratitude and loyalty to herself. This episode also clearly indicates or points to the way as to what the true natural relations should be between Britain and India, with the result of the welfare and prosperity of both, and the security and stability of British supremacy.
In my previous letters I have confined myself to the evil results—suicidal to Britain and destructive to India—of the present unnatural system of the administration and management of expenditure and the injustice of the financial relations between the two countries, loudly calling for a just apportionment of charge for purposes in which both are interested.
Without dwelling any further on this melancholy aspect, I shall at once proceed to the case to which I have alluded above, and in connexion with which there have been true statesmanlike and noble declarations made as to the right relations between Britain and India as they ought to exist. This case is in every way a bright chapter in the history of British India. The especially remarkable feature of this case is that notwithstanding the vehement and determined opposition to it from all Indian authorities for some thirty-six years, after this wise, natural, and righteous course was decided upon by her Majesty and the Secretary of State for India of the time, all the authorities, both here and in India, carried it out in the most loyal, earnest, and scrupulous manner and solicitude worthy of the British name and character—in striking contrast with the general conduct of these authorities, by which they have almost always frustrated and made dead letters of Acts and Resolutions of Parliament and royal proclamations and most solemn pledges on behalf of the British people by all sorts of un-English "subterfuges," "cheating devices" (Lytton), "hypocrisy" (Salisbury), "non-fulfilment of pledges" (Duke of Argyll, Lytton, and others), etc., in matters of the advancement and elevation of the Indian people to material and moral prosperity, and to real British rights and citizenship. Had they fortunately shown the same loyalty and true sense of their trust to these Acts and Resolutions of Parliament, to the solemn proclamations and pledges, as have been shown in the case I am referring to, what a different, prosperous, and grateful India would it have been to-day, blessing the name of Britain, and both to its glory and gain. It is not too late yet. It will be a pity if it ever becomes too late to prevent disaster.
On 22nd January, 1867, Lord Salisbury (then Lord Cranborne and Secretary of State for India) said (Hansard, vol. 185, p. 839) :— “But there are other considerations, and I think the hon. gentleman (Sir Henry Rawlinson) stated them very fairly and eloquently. I do not myself see our way at present to employing very largely the Natives of India in the regions under our immediate control. But it would be a great evil if the result of our dominion was that the Natives of India who were capable of government should be absolutely and hopelessly excluded from such a career. The great advantage of the existence of Native States is that they afford an outlet for statesmanlike capacity such as has been alluded to. I need not dwell upon the consideration to which the hon. gentleman so eloquently referred, bnt I think that the existence of a well-governed Native State is a real benefit, not only to the stability of our rule, but because, more than anything, it raises the self-respect of the Natives and forms an ideal to which the popular feelings aspire. . . . . Whatever treaties or engagements may be entered into, I hope that I shall not be looked upon by gentlemen of the Liberal party as very revolutionary if I say that the welfare of the people of India must override them all. I quite admit the temptations which a paramount power has to interpret that axiom rather for its own advantage than its own honour. There is no doubt of the existence of that temptation, but that does not diminish the truth of the maxim.” [The italics are mine.]
On 24th May, 1867, Lord Iddesleigh (then Sir Stafford Northcote and Secretary of State for India) said (Hansard vol. 187, p. 1068):—
“He believed that the change in education in India, and the fact that the Natives now saw what their system of government was and is, had told most beneficially on that country. He had, therefore, confidence that we might establish a state of things in Mysore which would have a happy effect on the administration of the country. What had taken place in other parts of India? Travancore forty years ago was in as bad a state as Mysore, yet its administration under British influence had so greatly improved that Travancore was now something like a model Native State. Our Indian policy should be founded on a broad basis. There might be difficulties; but what we had to aim at was to establish a system of Native States which might maintain themselves in a satisfactory relation. Keeping the virtues of Native States, and getting rid, as far as possible, of their disadvantages. We must look to the great natural advantages which the government of a Native State must necessarily have. Under the English system there were advantages which would probably never be under Native Administration—regularity, love of law and order and justice.”
Had Lord Iddesleigh lived he would have with pleasure seen that the advantages he refers to are being attained in the Native States; and in Mysore itself, as well as in several other States, they have been largely already attained. And under the eye of the British Government there is progress everywhere. Lord Iddesleigh proceeds :—
“ But native Administration had the advantage in sympathy between the governors and the governed. Governors were able to appreciate and understand the prejudices and wishes of the governed; especially in the case of Hindu States, the religious feelings of the people were enlisted in favour of their governors instead of being roused against us.* He had been told by gentlemen from India that nothing impressed them more than walking the streets of some Indian town, they looked up at the houses on each side and asked themselves, ‘what do we really know of these people—of their modes of thought, their feelings, their prejudices —and at what great disadvantage, in consequence, do we administer the government.’ The English Government must necessarily labour under great disadvantages, † and we should endeavour as far as possible to develop the system of Native government to bring out Native talent and statesmanship, and to enlist in the cause of government all that was great and good in them. Nothing could be more wonderful than our Empire in India; but we ought to consider on what conditions we hold it and how our predecessors held it. The greatness of the Mogul Empire depended on the liberal policy that was pursued by men like the great Emperor Akbar and his successors availing themselves of Hindu talent and assistance, and identifying themselves as far as possible with the people of the country. They ought to take a lesson from such circumstances. If they were to do their duty towards India they could only discharge that duty by obtaining assistance and counsel of all who are great and good in that country. It would be absurd in them to say that there was not a large fund of statesmanship and ability in the Indian character. They really must not be too proud. They were always ready to speak of the English government as so infinitely superior to anything in the way of Indian government. But if the Natives of India were disposed to be equally critical, it would be possible for them to find out weak places in the harness of the English administration. The system in India was one of great complexity. It was a system of checks and counter checks, and very often great abuses failed to be controlled from want of a proper knowledge of and sympathy with the Natives." [The italics are mine.]
On the same day Lord Salisbury, supporting Lord Iddesleigh, said (Hansard, vol. 187, p. 1073):—
"The general concurrence of opinion of those who know India best is that a number of well-governed small Native States are in the highest degree advantageous to the development of the political and moral condition of the people of India. The hon. gentleman (Mr. Laing) arguing in the strong official line seems to take the view that everything is right in British territory and everything dark in Native territory. Though he can cite the case of Oudh, I venture to doubt if it could be established as a general view of India as it exists at present. If Oudh is to be quoted against Native Government, the Report of the Orissa Famine, which will be presented in a few days, will be found to be another and far more terrible instance to be quoted against English rule. The British Government has never been guilty of the violence and illegality of Native Sovereigns. But it has faults of its own, which though they are far more guiltless in intention, are more terrible in effect. Its tendency to routine; its listless heavy heedlessness, sometimes the result of its elaborate organisation; a fear of responsibility, an extreme centralisation—all these results, traceable to causes for which no man is culpable, produce an amount of inefficiency which when reinforced by natural causes and circumstances, creates a terrible amount of misery. All these things must be taken into consideration when you compare our elaborate and artificial system of government with the more rough and ready system of India. In cases of emergency, unless you have men of peculiar character on the spot, the simple form of Oriental government will produce effects more satisfactory than the more elaborate system of English rule. I am not by this denying that our mission in India is to reduce to order, to civilise and develop the Native Governments we find there.* But I demur to that wholesale condemnation of a system of government which will be utterly intolerable on our own soil, but which has grown up amongst the people subjected to it. It has a fitness and congeniality for them impossible for us adequately to realise, but which compensate them to an enormous degree for the material evils which its rudeness in a great many cases produces. I may mention as an instance what was told me by Sir George Clerk, a distinguished member of the Council of India, respecting the Province of Kathiawar, in which the English and Native Governments are very much intermixed. There are no broad lines of frontier there, and a man can easily leap over the hedge from the Native into the English jurisdiction. Sir George Clerk told me that the Natives having little to carry with them were continually in the habit of migrating from the English into the Native jurisdiction, but that he never heard of an instance of a Native leaving his own to go into the English jurisdiction. 'This may be very bad taste on the part of the Natives; but you have to consider what promotes their happiness, suits their tastes, and tends to their moral development in their own way. If you intend to develop their moral nature only after an Anglo-Saxon type, you will make a conspicuous and disastrous defeat." [The italics are mine.]
In the above extract, Lord Salisbury says that the inefficiency reinforced by natural causes and circumstances creates a terrible amount of misery. These natural causes and circumstances which create the terrible amount of misery are pointed out by Lord Salisbury himself, as Secretary of State for India, in a Minute (29-4-75). He says "the injury is exaggerated in the case of India, where so much of the revenue is exported without a direct equivalent." And that under these causes and circumstances, the result is that "India must be bled," so that he truly shows that though under the British rule there is no personal violence, the present system of the administration of expenditure cannot but create and does "create a terrible amount of misery."
Further, the crude and defective system of administration under the old system of Native rule is all changed and cannot apply to the present administration in British India. Any alteration that may be deemed necessary to be made for remedying this "terrible amount of misery," would not involve in British India any alteration at all in the existing developed plan or system of the organisation of the administration.
Now, the moral of the above extracts from the speeches of Lords Salisbury and Iddesleigh is clear. Under the present system of administration of government and expenditure and unjust financial relations, in the very nature of things, there is a perpetual and inevitable result of terrible misery, of slavery (Macaulay), absolute hopelessness of higher life or career, despair, self-abasement, without any self-respect (Salisbury), extreme destitution and suffering (Bright), extreme poverty (Lawrence, Cromer, Barbour, Colvin), degradation (Monroe), etc., etc. And as a consequence of such deplorable results, an inherent and inevitable “danger of the most serious order” (Lord R. Churchill) to the stability of British supremacy. British rule under such circumstances can only continue to be a foreign crushing tyranny, leading the people to yearn (the Duke of Devonshire) to get rid of their European rulers, etc., etc.
On the other hand, (Salisbury) “the existence of a well-governed Native State is a real benefit, not only to the stability of the British rule, but more than anything it raises the self-respect of the Natives and forms an ideal to which the popular feeling aspires.” And “that a number of well-governed small Native States are in the highest degree advantageous to the development of the political and moral” (I may add, the material) “condition of the people of India.” Lord Iddesleigh says on the same lines: “What we had to aim at was to establish a system of Native States which might maintain themselves in a satisfactory relation.” And what is of far more importance, he actually inaugurated the great experiment, by which he proposed to solve the great problem, “which should at once afford a guarantee for the good government of the people and for the security of British rights and interests," and to which I desire to draw the attention of the Commission. In short, the lesson of the extracts is that the British Indian administration as it exists at present is positively and seriously dangerous to the British supremacy, and of terrible misery to the people; while a system of Native States will raise the people, and at the same time firmly secure the stability of the British supremacy and largely conduce to the prosperity of both countries—Britain and India.
Now comes the great merit—which will always be remembered by Indians with deep gratitude—of these two Statesmen (Salisbury and Iddesleigh). They did not rest satisfied with mere declaration of fine and great sentiments and then sleep over them, as has been done on many an occasion to the misfortune of poor India. No, they then showed that they had the courage of their convictions and had confidence in the true statesmanship of their views. In this good work her Majesty took a warm interest and encouraged them to carry it out. The result was the memorable--and ever to be remembered with gratitude— despatch of 16th April, 1867, of Lord Iddesleigh, for the restoration of Mysore to the Native rule, notwithstanding thirty-six years of determined opposition of the authorities to that step (Parl. Ret. 239, 30/4/'67).
And now I come to the episode to which I have referred above, and about which I write with great gratification and gratitude, of the conduct of all the authorities in both countries and of all the Anglo-Indian officials who had any share in this good work, backed as I have said already, by the good-hearted and influential interest and support of her Majesty herself. They may have made some errors of judgment, but there was universally perfect sincerity and loyalty to the trust. Among those concerned (and whose names it is a pleasure to me to give) were, as Secretaries of State for India, Lord Iddesleigh, the Duke of Argyll, Lord Salisbury, Viscount Cranbrook, and the Duke of Devonshire (from 1867 till 1881, when the late Maharaja was invested with power); as Viceroys, Lord Lawrence, Lord Mayo, Lord Northbrook, Lord Lytton, and Lord Ripon; and lastly, the Chief Commissioners and other officials of Mysore. The chief merit in the conduct of all concerned was this. Lord Iddesleigh laid down in his despatch of 16th of April, 1867:—
"Without entering upon any minute examination of the terms of the Treaties of 1799, her Majesty's Government recognise, in the policy which dictated that settlement, a desire to provide for the maintenance of an Indian dynasty on the throne of Mysore, upon terms which should at once afford a guarantee for the good government of the people and for the security of British rights and interests. Her Majesty is animated by the same desire, and shares the views to which I have referred. . . . Her Majesty desires to maintain that family on the throne in the person of his Highness's adopted son. . . . It is therefore the intention of her Majesty that the young Prince should have the advantage of an education suitable to his rank and position and calculated to prepare him for the duties of administration." [The italics are mine.]
This being once settled, though against all previous opposition, and necessitating the withdrawal of Europeans from the Services, all the authorities and officials concerned, to their honour and praise, instead of putting any obstacles in the way, or trying to frustrate the above intentions, discharged their trust most loyally, and with every earnestness and care and solicitude to carry the work to success. The Blue-Books on Mysore from the despatch of 16th April, 1867, to the installation of the late Maharaja in 1881, is a bright chapter in the history of British India, both in the justice, righteousness, and statesmanship of the decision, and the loyalty and extreme care of every detail in carrying out that decision—with success and satisfactory results in both objects set forth in the despatch, viz., “the good government of the people, and the security of British rights and interests.”
I wish the India Office would make a return on Mysore relations and affairs up to date, in continuation of Ret. No. 1 of 1881 (c. 3026), to show how the good and creditable work has been continued up to the present time. I think I need not enter here into any details of this good work from 1867 to 1881 of the British officials: the Blue-Books tell all that. Of the work of the late Maharaja from 1881 till his death at the end of 1894, it would be enough for me to give a very brief statement from the last Address of the Dewan to the Representative Assembly held at Mysore on 1st October, 1895, on the results of the late Maharaja’s administration during nearly fourteen years of his reign, as nearly as possible in the Dewan’s words. The Maharaja was invested with power on 25th March, 1881. Just previous to it, the State had encountered a most disastrous famine by which a fifth of the population had been swept away, and the State had run into a debt of 80 lakhs of rupees to the British Government. The cash balance had become reduced to a figure insufficient for the ordinary requirements of the administration. Every source of revenue was at its lowest, and the severe retrenchments which followed had left every department of State in an enfeebled condition. Such was the beginning. It began with liabilities exceeding the assets by 30 3/4 lakhs, and with an annual income less than the annual expenditure by 1 1/4 lakhs.
Comparing 1880-1 with 1894-5, the annual revenue rose from 103 to 180 1/2 lakhs, or 75·24 per cent., and after spending on a large and liberal scale on all works and purposes of public utility, the net assets amounted to over 176 lakhs in 1894-5, in lieu of the net liability of 30 3/4 lakhs with which his Highness’s reign began in 1881.
| Rs. | |
|---|---|
| In 1881, the balance of State Funds was ... | 24,07,438 |
| Capital outlay on State Railways ... | 25,19,198 |
| Against a liability to the British Government of ... | 80,00,000 |
Leaving a balance of liability of Rs. 30 3/4 lakhs.
On 30th June, 1895 :
| Assets— | ||
|---|---|---|
| (1) Balance of State Funds ... | 1,27,23,615 | |
| (2) Investment on account of Railway Loan Repayment Fund ... | 27,81,500 | |
| (3) Capital outlay on Mysore-Harihar Railway ... | 1,48,03,306 | |
| (4) Capital outlay on other Railways ... | 41,33,390 | |
| (5) Unexpended portion of Capital borrowed for Mysore-Harihar Railway (with British Government) ... | 15,79,495 | |
| 3,60,21,306 | ||
| Liabilities— | ||
| (1) Local Railway Loan ... | Rs. | 20,00,000 |
| (2) English Railway Loan ... | „ | 1,63,82,801 |
| 1,83,82,801 | ||
| Net Assets ... ... ... | Rs. 1,76,38,505 | |
| Add Other Assets— | ||
| Capital outlay on original Irrigation Works ... | Rs. | 99,08,935 |
Besides the above expenditure from current revenue, there is the subsidy to the British Government of about Rs. 25,00,000 a year, or a total of about Rs. 3,70,00,000 in the fifteen years from 1880-1 to 1894-5, and the Maharaja’s civil list of about Rs. 180,00,000, during the fifteen years also paid from the current revenue. And all this together with increase in expenditure in every department. Under the circumstances above described, the administration at the start of his Highness’s reign was necessarily very highly centralised. The Dewan, or the Executive Administrative head, had the direct control, without the intervention of departmental heads of all the principal departments, such as the Land Revenue, Forests, Excise, Mining, Police, Education, Mujroyi, Legislative. As the finances improved, and as department after department was put into good working order and showed signs of expansion, separate heads of departments were appointed for Forests and Police in 1885, for Excise in 1889, for Mujroyi in 1891, and for Mining in 1894. His Highness was able to resolve upon the appointment of a separate Land Revenue Commissioner only in the latter part of 1894. Improvements were made in other departments— Local and Municipal Funds, Legislation, Education, etc. There are no wails which unfortunately the Finance Ministers of British India are obliged to raise, year after year, of fall in Exchange, over-burdening taxation, etc., etc.
And all the above good results are side by side with an increase of population of 18·34 per cent. in the ten years from 1881 to 1891, and there is reason to believe that during the last four years the ratio of increase was even higher. During the fourteen years the rate of mortality is estimated to have declined 6·7 per mille.
But there is still the most important and satisfactory feature to come, viz., that all this financial prosperity was secured not by resort to new taxation in any form or shape. In the very nature of things the present system of administration and management of Indian expenditure in British India cannot ever produce such results, even though a Gladstone undertook the work. Such is the result of good administration in a Native State at the very beginning. What splendid prospect is in store for the future if, as heretofore, it is allowed to develop itself to the level of the British system with its own Native Services, and not bled as poor British India is.
Lord Iddesleigh is dead (though his name will never be forgotten in India, and how he would have rejoiced !), but well may her Majesty, Lord Salisbury, and all others concerned in it, and the British people, be proud of this brilliant result of a righteous and statesmanlike act, and may feel secure of the sincere and solid loyalty, gratitude, and attachment of the rulers and people of Mysore to the British supremacy.
Here, then, is the whole problem of the right and natural administration of expenditure, etc., and stability of British supremacy solved, and that most successfully, by Lords Salisbury and Iddesleigh. It is now clear, by actual facts and operation, that the present system of expenditure, in all aspects of the administration of British India, is full of evil to the people and danger to British supremacy, while, on the other hand, " a number of well-governed Native States, " under the active control and supremacy of Britain, will be full of benefit and blessing both to Britain and India and a firm foundation for British supremacy. And all this prophecy of Lords Salisbury and Iddesleigh has been triumphantly fulfilled. Lord Iddesleigh set to himself the problem "which should at once afford a guarantee for the good government of the people and for the security of British rights and interests," and most successfully solved it.
The obvious conclusion is that the only natural and satisfactory relations between an alien supremacy and the people of India can be established on this basis alone. There are these obvious advantages in these relations :—
The British supremacy becomes perfectly secure and founded upon the gratitude and affection of the people, who, though under such supremacy, would feel as being under their own rulers and as being guided and protected by a mighty supreme power.
Every State thus formed, from the very nature of its desire for self-preservation, will cling to the supreme power as its best security against disturbance by any other State.
The division in a number of States becomes a natural and potent power for good in favour of the stability of the British supremacy. There will be no temptation to any one State to discard that supremacy, while, on the other hand, the supreme Government, having complete control and power over the whole government of each State, will leave no chance for any to go astray. Every instinct of self-interest and self-preservation, of gratitude, of high aspirations, and of all the best parts of human nature, will naturally be on the side and in favour of British supremacy which gave birth to these States. There will be an emulation among them to vie with each other in governing in the best way possible, under the eye and control of the supreme Government on their actions, leaving no chance for misgovernment. Each will desire to produce the best Administration Report every year. In short, this natural system has all the elements of consolidation of British power, of loyalty, and stability, and of prosperity of both countries. On the other hand, under the present system, all human nature and instincts are against you, and must inevitably end in disintegration, rebellion, and disaster. No grapes from thistles ! Evil will have its nemesis. I hope and pray that this Commission will rise to the height of its mission, and accomplish it to the glory of this country and the prosperity of both.
I must not be misunderstood. When I use the words "Native States," I do not for a moment mean that these new States are to revert to the old system of government of Native rule. Not at all. The system of all departments that exists at present, the whole mode of government, must not only remain as it is, but must go on improving till it reaches as nearly as possible the level of the more complete mode of British government that exists in this country. The change to be made is, that these States are to be governed by Native agency, on the same lines as at present, by employing, as the Duke of Devonshire says, "the best and most intelligent of the Natives," or as Lord Iddesleigh says, "all that was great and good in them."
One question naturally presents itself. Are new dynastic Indian rajahs to be created for these new States ? That is a question that men like Lord Salisbury himself and the Indian authorities are best able to answer. There may be difficulties in dynastic succession. If so, the best mode of the headship under some suitable title of these States may be by appointment by Government, and aided by a representative Council. This mode has certain evident advantages, viz., questions of dynastic succession may be avoided, Government will be free to secure the best man for the post, and Government will then have complete control over the States, especially with an English Resident, as in all Native States at present. If thought necessary, this control may be made still more close by having at the beginning for some time an English joint-Administrator instead of a Resident.
Sir Charles Dilke has, in one of his letters to me, said :—
"I also agree as to reduction of Europeans (so far as the non-military people go). Indeed, I agree without limit, and would substitute for our direct rule a military protectorate of Native States, as I have often said."
In another letter to me, which is published in the September number of India, in 1893, Sir Charles dwells upon the same subject at some length, proposing to follow up the case of Mysore and to divide India into a number of Native States.
With regard to the financial relations between Britain and India, whether for military or civil charges, I have already expressed my views in my last representation. I would not, therefore, make any further remarks here.
Once this natural and righteous system of government by Native States is adopted, so as to make the administration of expenditure fully productive of good results to both countries, I may with every confidence hope that the authorities, as in the case of Mysore, will loyally and scrupulously do their best to carry out the plan to success by establishing in India every necessary machinery for preparation, examinations, and tests of character and fitness of the Indians " to (as Lord Iddesleigh says) develop the system of Native government, to bring out Native talent and statesmanship, and to enlist in the cause of government all that was great and good in them."
The prevention and cure of the evils of the present material and moral bleeding, arising from the existing system of the administration and management of expenditure, from unjust financial relations between the two countries, and for the redemption of the honour of this country from the dishonour of the violation of the most solemn and binding pledges, are absolutely necessary, if India is to be well governed, if British supremacy is to be made thoroughly stable, and if both countries are to be made prosperous by a market for trade of nearly 300,000,000 of civilised and prosperous people.
I do not here consider any other plan of Government to secure effectively the double object laid down by Lord Iddesleigh, because I think the plan proposed and carried out by him is the most natural and the best, and most secure for the continuance of British supremacy.
I also do not enter into any details, as all possible difficulties of details, and the means by which they were overcome, are all recorded in the Mysore Blue-Books.
I submit to the Commission that unless the patriotism and prosperity of the people of India are drawn to the side of British supremacy, no plan or mode of government, under the existing system of expenditure, will be of any good either to British supremacy or to the Indian people. Evil and peril to both is the only dismal outlook. On the other hand, a number of Native States, according to the noble views and successful work of Lords Salisbury and Iddesleigh, will contribute vastly both to the gain and glory of the British people, to vast expansion of trade, and to the prosperity and affection of the Indian hundreds of millions of the human race.
If India is thus strengthened in prosperity, and patriotically satisfied in British supremacy, I cannot feel the least fear of Russia ever dreaming of invading India. Without any military help from England, and without any large European army, India will be all sufficient in itself to repel any invasion, and to maintain British supremacy for her own and Britain's sake.
I hope earnestly that this Commission will, as Sir Louis Mallet has urged, grapple with the disease of the evil results of the present system of expenditure, instead of, like other past Commissions and Committees, keeping to the habit of merely palliating symptoms. I do not much intervene in examining details of departmental expenditure, such examination at proper intervals, as used to be the case in the time of the Company, serves the important purpose of keeping the Government up to mark in care of expenditure. But unless the whole Government is put on a natural basis, all examinations of details of departmental expenditures will be only so much "palliating with symptoms," and will bring no permanent good and strength either to the Indian people or to the British supremacy.
I offer to be cross-examined on all my representations.
As before, I shall send a copy of this to every member of the Commission.
Yours truly,
Dadabhai Naoroji.
Notes
- *. Submitted to the Welby Commission, 21st March 1896.
- *. The same can be said about the Muhammadans and other people.
- †. The greatest of them is the economic evil which Lord Salisbury has truly called the bleeding of the country.
- *. This is being actually done. Every effort is being made to bring the administration of the Native States to the level of the organisation of the British system which is not a little to the credit of the British Government.